HOME
PRODUCTS
ABOUT
CUSTOMERS
CONTACT
Current location:Home>Comparison Guide>difference between vsi crusher and jaw crusher

Jaw Crusher vs Vertical Shaft Impact Crusher: A Comprehensive Comparison

vsi crusher vs jaw crusher

Structure

vsi crusher

A VSI (Vertical Shaft Impact) crusher is designed to produce high-quality, cubical-shaped aggregate from various types of materials. Its main components include:

jaw crusher

A jaw crusher primarily consists of:

Rotor: The central rotating element of the VSI crusher that accelerates the material to high speeds.

Impactor: Located around the rotor, it imparts high-velocity impact on the material.

Cavity: The area where the material is accelerated and impacted to break it into smaller pieces.

Feed Hopper: The entry point where the material is fed into the crusher.

Discharge Port: The exit point where the crushed material is ejected.

Frame: The structural support for all components, often made from robust steel.

Fixed Jaw Plate: A stationary component mounted on the machine frame, usually made of durable cast steel.

Movable Jaw Plate: A component that moves back and forth, connected to a hinge mechanism.

Jaw Plate Support: Structures that support and secure the jaw plates, ensuring stability and durability.

Eccentric Shaft: Transfers power to the movable jaw plate, typically driven by an electric motor.

Flywheel: Stores and releases energy to help reduce vibration.

Base and Frame: The support structure for the entire machine, bearing all working components.

Working Principle

vsi crusher

The VSI crusher operates on the principle of high-speed impact. The working process involves:

jaw crusher

Jaw crushers operate based on compression and impact. The process includes:

Feeding: Material is fed into the rotor from the feed hopper.

Impact: The accelerated material is projected towards the impact plates or anvils where it is crushed by high-velocity impacts.

Feeding: Material enters the crusher through the feed opening.

Crushing: The movable jaw plate compresses the material between itself and the fixed jaw plate, breaking it down.

Technical Specifications

vsi crusher
jaw crusher

VSI Crusher

rushing Stage: Used primarily for shaping and fine crushing.

Applicable Material Hardness: Suitable for materials with high abrasiveness and hardness, including rocks and minerals with compressive strengths above 150 MPa.

Crushing Ratio: Typically around 4:1 to 8:1, depending on the material and application.

Feed Size: Maximum feed size generally ranges from 30 mm to 100 mm, depending on the model.

Output Size: Output sizes can be adjusted, usually ranging from 0.075 mm to 30 mm.

Output Particle Shape: Produces cubical or angular particles with consistent shape.

Production Capacity: Generally ranges from 30 t/h to 600 t/h, depending on the machine size and configuration.

Jaw Crusher

rushing Stage: Primarily used for primary crushing.

Applicable Material Hardness: Suitable for materials with compressive strength between 150 to 300 MPa.

Crushing Ratio: Typically ranges from 6:1 to 10:1.

Feed Size: Maximum feed size ranges from 150 mm to 1500 mm.

Output Size: Discharge size is adjustable, generally from 10 mm to 300 mm.

Output Particle Shape: Typically irregular due to the compression mechanism; particles may be cuboidal, rectangular, or irregular.

Production Capacity: Generally ranges from 20 t/h to 1500 t/h.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages

VSI Crusher

High Cubical Shaped Product: Produces high-quality, cubical-shaped aggregate.

Versatility: Capable of processing a wide range of materials, including hard and abrasive types.

Efficient: High efficiency in reducing material size with low energy consumption.

Low Wear Costs: Reduced wear and tear due to the use of advanced materials and designs.

Jaw Crusher

Simple Structure: Easy to manufacture and maintain, with low cost.

Ease of Operation: Simple and convenient to operate and adjust.

High Durability: Made from wear-resistant materials, leading to a long service life.

High Production Capacity: Suitable for crushing large blocks of material.

Disadvantages

VSI Crusher

Initial Cost: Higher initial investment compared to some other crushers.

<Maintenance:Requires regular maintenance and replacement of wear parts.

Production Limits: May not be suitable for extremely large feed sizes.

Jaw Crusher

High Energy Consumption: Can be energy-intensive, especially with hard materials.

Uneven Particle Size: Crushed material may be uneven in size.

Noise and Vibration: Generates significant noise and vibration during operation.

Applications

VSI Crusher

Construction Aggregates: Producing high-quality aggregates for construction projects.

Mining: Crushing and shaping ore for further processing.

Industrial Minerals: Processing industrial minerals like limestone and sandstone.

Recycling: Reprocessing demolition waste and concrete to produce recycled aggregates.

Jaw Crusher

Mining: Crushing ores, coal, and other minerals.

Construction Materials: Producing aggregate for construction and processing demolition waste.

Chemical Industry: Primary crushing of raw chemical materials.

Metallurgy: Initial crushing of ores and smelting materials.

Maintenance and Costs

Maintenance

VSI Crusher

Regular Inspections: Frequent checks on rotor, impactor, and other wear parts.

Wear Parts Replacement: Timely replacement of wear components to ensure optimal performance.

Lubrication: Regular lubrication of moving parts to prevent damage.

Jaw Crusher

Regular Checks: Inspect jaw plates, eccentric shaft, and other key components for wear.

Lubrication: Regularly lubricate moving parts.

Replacement: Replace worn jaw plates and other consumables as needed.

Costs

VSI Crusher

Initial Investment: Higher initial cost compared to some other types of crushers.

Operating Costs: Includes energy consumption and maintenance of wear parts.

Long-Term Use: Durable design leads to reduced operational costs over time due to efficient performance and lower wear.

Jaw Crusher

Initial Investment: High purchase cost depending on the model and size.

Operating Costs: Includes energy consumption, maintenance, and repair.

Long-Term Use: Lower maintenance costs and long service life provide good long-term economic benefits.

Summary

Jaw crushers are essential for primary crushing in various industries, offering a range of technical parameters and operational features. Their simplicity, durability, and high production capacity make them a preferred choice, though considerations regarding energy consumption and maintenance should be factored into selection and use.

The VSI crusher is a versatile and efficient machine for producing high-quality, cubical-shaped aggregate from various materials. With its ability to handle hard and abrasive materials, it is widely used in construction, mining, and recycling industries. While it requires a higher initial investment and regular maintenance, its advantages in product quality and efficiency make it a valuable asset for many crushing operations.

Are you still hesitating about how to choose a crushing equipment? Click the button below to learn more details

Chat Online

CASEProduction Site

Manufacturer's strength

REQUEST FOR QUOTATION

Free consultation on related issues.

Contact Us
How can we help you?
Chat Online
You can also email us at dingli@dinglicrusher.com